NYSSWA All-State Selections
| YEAR | NAME | POSITION | TEAM | CLASS |
| 1983 | Bruce Baldi | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 1988 | Chris Ford | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| Alberto Cabezas Talavero | Kicker | 1st Team | C | |
| 1989 | Robert Pagano | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 1991 | Derrick Harby | Quarterback | 1st Team | C |
| 1992 | Todd Lambrecht | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 1994 | Kirk Aikens | Running Back | 1st Team |
C (POY) |
| Glen Cooper | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C | |
| Tim Bartlett | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C | |
| Jason LaTourette | Linebacker | 1st Team | C | |
| 1995 | Seth Reynolds | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 1997 | Seth Stanton | Running Back | 1st Team | C |
| Kyle Wood | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C | |
| Chris MacNeill | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C | |
| 1998 | Chad Scott | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 1999 | Chris Eisele | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| Justin MacDonald | Linebacker | 1st Team | C | |
| 2000 | David Stanton | Tight End | 1st Team | C |
| Mike Martin | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C | |
| 2001 | David Stanton | Linebacker | 1st Team | C |
| Andy Moody | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | C | |
| 2002 | James Coughlin | Defensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| Kirk Fletcher | Linebacker | 3rd Team | C | |
| 2003 | Sean Kelly | Offensive Line | 1st Team | C |
| 2004 | Wisey Askerzadeh | Running Back | 1st Team | C |
| Jeff Bolivar | Linebacker | 1st Team | C | |
| Trevor Moody | Offensive Line | 3rd Team | C | |
| 2005 | Will Neale | Offensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| Jared Boice | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Robert MacLachlan | Linebacker | 3rd Team | D | |
| 2006 | Shawn McGrath | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| 2007 | Richard Fletcher | Running Back | 1st Team | D (POY) |
| Casey Killian | Running Back | 1st Team | D | |
| Drew Hammond | Offensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Brad Hodges | Offensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Wade Hammond | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Sean Knapp | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Logan Wood | Running Back | 2nd Team | D | |
| Chris Mead | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | D | |
| 2008 | Phil Hanley | Running Back | 1st Team | D |
| Chris Mead | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D | |
| Cody Reed | Defensive Back | 1st Team | D | |
| Kenny Reynolds | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | D | |
| Chad Gardepe | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | D | |
| 2009 | Phil Hanley | Running Back | 3rd Team | C |
| 2010 | Christian Howe | Running Back | 1st Team | D |
| Justin DiJulio | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | D | |
| Nick Shiels | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | D | |
| Bobby Albro | Defensive Line | 3rd Team | D | |
| 2011 | Justin DiJulio | Offensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| Nick Shiels | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | D | |
| Mike Beers | Running Back | 3rd Team | D | |
| 2012 | Mike Beers | Linebacker | 2nd Team | D |
| 2014 | Tyler Griffin | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | D |
| Dawson Beers | Running Back | Honorable Mention | D | |
| Quinn Harby | Linebacker | Honorable Mention | D | |
| 2015 | Dawson Beers | Running Back | 1st Team | D |
| Kevin Malia | Offensive Line | 2nd Team | D | |
| 2017 | Bailey Wood | Offensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| 2018 | Jordan Blincoe | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| Dylan Jacob | Defensive Back | Honorable Mention | D | |
| 2019 | Nick Lamoreaux | Linebacker | 1st Team | D |
| Morgan Condon | Offensive End | 2nd Team | D | |
| Jordan Blincoe | Defensive Line | 2nd Team | D | |
| Dylan Jacob | Defensive Back | 2nd Team | D | |
| Cody Ray | Offensive End | Honorable Mention | D | |
| 2022 | Colby Phraner | Defensive Line | 1st Team | D |
| Tony McClenon | Running Back | Honorable Mention | D | |
| 2023 | Colby Phraner | Defensive Line | 2nd Team | D |
| 2024 | Darrin Walley | Linebacker | 2nd Team | D |
| Landon Taylor | Offensive Line | Honorable Mention | D | |
